Why are my MIG welds so high?

High MIG welds often result from incorrect voltage settings, improper wire feed speed, inadequate gas shielding, or wrong electrode stick-out length.

Common Causes of High MIG Welds

Incorrect voltage settings

One of the primary reasons for high MIG welds is the use of incorrect voltage settings. If the voltage is too high, the arc can become too aggressive and force the molten metal to pile up instead of spreading evenly. Conversely, if the voltage is too low, there might not be enough heat to penetrate the metal, leading to a raised weld bead. For a mild steel thickness of 1/8 inch, a typical voltage setting might range from 17 to 19 volts. Always refer to the manufacturer’s recommendations or use a welding voltage chart to determine the ideal settings for your specific material and thickness.

Why are my MIG welds so high

Improper wire feed speed

The wire feed speed dictates how fast the MIG wire is fed into the weld pool. If the speed is too high, you’ll end up with excessive wire piling up, causing high welds. On the other hand, a slow wire feed speed can cause the wire to burn back into the contact tip, leading to an unstable arc and poor weld formation. For example, a 0.030-inch diameter wire typically requires a feed speed of 150 to 200 inches per minute for mild steel. To achieve the best results, it’s crucial to balance the wire feed speed with the chosen voltage. The wire feed speed chart can be a valuable resource in this context.

Inadequate gas shielding

Gas shielding protects the weld pool from atmospheric contaminants like oxygen and nitrogen. When there’s inadequate gas shielding, the contaminants can cause porosity and a rough weld bead profile. The cost implications of poor gas shielding can be significant, as you may need to redo the weld or, in severe cases, replace the material. To ensure optimal shielding, it’s essential to choose the right type of gas (like 75% Argon and 25% CO2 for mild steel) and maintain a consistent flow rate, usually around 20 to 25 cubic feet per hour. If you’re uncertain about gas selection, the welding gas guide on Wikipedia offers insights.

Wrong electrode stick-out length

Electrode stick-out, or the length of the wire that protrudes from the contact tip, plays a crucial role in determining weld quality. A longer stick-out can decrease the current, causing a taller weld bead due to reduced arc force. A typical stick-out length for MIG welding is about 1/4 to 3/8 inches. However, this can vary based on the specific application and material thickness. Ensure that you regularly monitor and adjust the electrode stick-out to maintain the desired weld bead profile. For more detailed information on electrode considerations, check the electrode guide on Wikipedia.

Effects of High Welds on Metal Work

Reduced joint strength

High welds can seriously compromise the structural integrity of a joint. When welds are raised excessively, the added height can create stress points, potentially leading to premature failure. For instance, in a metal structure expected to bear a weight of 5,000 pounds, a compromised weld might reduce this capability by up to 20%, risking a maximum weight of only 4,000 pounds. This reduction can result in increased maintenance costs, potential property damage, and even safety hazards. To understand the science behind joint strength and welding, the Welding Joint Wikipedia page offers valuable insights.

Aesthetically unappealing finishes

From a visual perspective, high welds can make a finished metalwork piece look uneven and unprofessional. If the metalwork is a component of a product being sold, this imperfection can decrease its market value by a considerable margin. For example, a handcrafted metal table might sell for $500 with perfect welds, but the same table with high welds could see its price drop to $350 or even lower, purely due to aesthetic reasons. For artisans and businesses, this represents a direct hit to their profits. Aesthetic considerations in metalwork are detailed on the Metal Finishing Wikipedia page.


Increased likelihood of weld defects

High welds are often indicators of underlying problems in the welding process. This can lead to defects such as porosity, cracking, or inclusion. For instance, a high weld caused by excessive wire feed speed might hide pockets of trapped gas (porosity) within the weld. Over time, these imperfections can grow and cause the weld to crack. Repairing such defects can be costly, both in terms of materials and labor. If a company is producing 100 metal parts per day and 10% have defects due to high welds, the cumulative costs in terms of time, material waste, and repair labor could exceed $10,000 per month, depending on the specific industry and region. To dive deeper into welding defects and their implications, the Welding Defects Wikipedia page is a helpful resource.

The Importance of Machine Calibration

Regular maintenance for consistent performance

Regular maintenance is pivotal to ensuring your welding machine functions optimally. Let’s consider an example: if a machine operates for an average of 8 hours a day, over a month, tiny deviations can accumulate, leading to noticeable discrepancies in performance. Without regular checks, these discrepancies can worsen. For instance, a neglected machine might use 15% more electricity, adding an extra $50 to the monthly power bill. Moreover, uneven wear and tear can reduce the machine’s lifespan from a potential 10 years to just 6 years. This premature aging implies replacing the machine sooner, a significant cost given that a quality MIG welder can range from $500 to $2,000 or even more. For an in-depth look at welding machine maintenance, the Welding Equipment Maintenance Wikipedia page is insightful.

Understanding machine specifications

Grasping the ins and outs of your machine’s specifications is crucial. It’s like understanding the needs and capabilities of a high-performance sports car. Every welding machine comes with specific power ratings, duty cycles, voltage settings, and wire feed speed ranges. For instance, a welder rated at 200 amperes with a 20% duty cycle means it can weld continuously for 2 minutes out of every 10-minute period without overheating. Exceeding this can result in reduced efficiency, with the machine operating at only 85% of its optimal capacity, which can lead to inconsistent weld quality. Furthermore, not adhering to specified voltage settings can result in increased operational costs. Suppose the welder operates outside its recommended settings. In that case, this could lead to a 10% increase in material waste due to weld defects, which can translate to a loss of $100 or more monthly, depending on the scale of operations. Comprehensive insights on machine specifications can be found on the Welding Machine Specifications Wikipedia page.

Techniques to Achieve Optimal Weld Profiles

Pre-weld preparations and practices

Before initiating the welding process, proper preparation can make a world of difference in achieving clean, consistent weld profiles. First, always ensure the workpiece surfaces are clean and free of contaminants. Even a minute trace of oil or rust can lead to weld porosity, which can compromise the weld’s strength by up to 30%. Investing in a quality metal cleaner, which may cost around $20 for a gallon, can prevent these issues.

Secondly, always clamp and secure the pieces you’re welding. Movement during the welding process can lead to uneven weld profiles and can even cause arc instability. Investing in a set of quality welding clamps, which can range from $10 to $50 each, ensures that the workpieces remain stationary during the process. More on pre-weld preparations can be found on the Welding Preparation Wikipedia page.

Perfecting the welding technique

The way one handles the welding gun plays a pivotal role in determining the quality of the weld bead. A consistent travel speed and angle ensure even heat distribution and bead formation. For instance, maintaining a 10 to 15-degree push or pull angle relative to the direction of welding helps in optimal gas shielding and better penetration. The speed at which the electrode travels over the workpiece also matters. A slower speed may cause excessive buildup, while a faster speed can lead to inadequate fusion. Practicing on scrap metal before working on the final piece can help perfect this balance. Training courses, which might cost around $200 to $500 depending on the complexity and duration, can provide valuable hands-on experience. Detailed techniques and tips are available on the Welding Techniques Wikipedia page.

it looks bad for my mig first pass

Tips for selecting the right welding parameters

Choosing the right welding parameters is akin to setting up a musical instrument for optimal sound quality. It requires a delicate balance of voltage, wire feed speed, and gas flow rate. For instance, a slight increase in voltage from 18V to 20V can change the weld bead’s appearance from convex to flat or concave. Such minor adjustments can drastically alter the weld’s quality and strength. Always refer to the manufacturer’s guidelines when setting up your machine. For a standard MIG welding machine, using 0.030-inch wire, the ideal wire feed speed might range between 150 and 250 inches per minute. Properly setting these parameters can lead to a 20% increase in operational efficiency, saving both time and material costs. For a deeper dive into selecting the right welding parameters, consult the Welding Parameters Wikipedia page.

Role of Welding Wire Selection

Wire materials and their impact

Choosing the right welding wire material is crucial for achieving a strong, durable, and corrosion-resistant weld. Common materials include ER70S-6 for mild steel, ER308L for stainless steel, and ER4043 for aluminum. Each material type provides unique attributes to the weld. For example, ER70S-6, costing around $10 per pound, contains higher levels of manganese and silicon, making it ideal for welding on dirty or rusty steel. This specific wire material offers good wetting action and produces a smooth weld bead.

However, using an inappropriate wire for a given base metal can reduce the weld’s strength by up to 50%. Furthermore, mismatched materials can lead to accelerated corrosion, which might result in the welded component’s failure within just 2-3 years instead of its expected lifespan of 10 years or more. A comprehensive breakdown of wire materials and their properties is available on the Welding Wire Materials Wikipedia page.

Wire diameter considerations

Selecting the right wire diameter is equally vital. Common diameters range from 0.023 inches for thin sheet metals to 0.045 inches or even larger for thicker materials. Using a 0.023-inch wire, which may cost about $25 for a 2-pound spool, allows for finer control on thin materials, reducing the risk of burn-through. On the flip side, using this thin wire on thick material may not provide adequate penetration, leading to weak welds.

In contrast, a 0.045-inch wire, priced around $40 for a 2-pound spool, provides deep penetration and a larger weld pool, suitable for thicker metals but can be excessive for thin sheets. Always match the wire diameter with the material’s thickness and the welder’s power capabilities. This ensures optimal fusion, reduces spatter, and maximizes the efficiency of the welding process. For more insights on the importance of wire diameter, the Welding Wire Diameter Wikipedia page is a valuable resource.

Environmental Factors that Can Influence Weld Height

Ambient temperature effects

The ambient temperature, or the surrounding air temperature, plays a significant role in the welding process. Welding in colder environments, for instance, at temperatures below 50°F, can lead to rapid cooling rates post-welding. This can result in increased brittleness and higher susceptibility to cracking. In such scenarios, pre-heating the material, which might incur an added energy cost of about $10 to $50 per session depending on the material and equipment, becomes essential. On the contrary, welding in hotter environments, above 100°F, can cause the base metal to reach its melting point quicker, leading to potential burn-through or overly high welds. Proper equipment calibration to account for ambient temperature is crucial. Further understanding on the subject can be derived from the Ambient Temperature Welding Wikipedia page.

Impact of humidity and moisture

Humidity and moisture can significantly affect the weld quality. High humidity, especially levels exceeding 70%, can introduce moisture into the welding arc. This moisture can cause porosity in the weld bead, which, in severe cases, can reduce weld strength by up to 40%. Moreover, welding consumables, like electrodes or flux, can absorb moisture from the environment. A flux-coated electrode, for example, can absorb moisture over time if stored in high humidity conditions. Using such electrodes can lead to weld defects, compromising the integrity of the weld.

For shielded metal arc welding (SMAW) or stick welding, using a damp electrode can increase the chances of inclusions and porosity. Therefore, storing electrodes in a dry environment or using electrode ovens, which might cost between $100 to $500 depending on capacity and brand, is crucial to prevent moisture absorption. To delve deeper into the implications of humidity and moisture in welding, the Welding in Humid Conditions Wikipedia page offers detailed insights.

What voltage setting is ideal for 1/8 inch mild steel?

A typical voltage setting for 1/8 inch mild steel is between 17 to 19 volts.

How does wire feed speed impact my welds?

If your wire feed speed is too high, it can cause excessive wire buildup, leading to high welds. Conversely, a slow feed speed can cause inadequate fusion. For a 0.030-inch diameter wire, an ideal speed is between 150 to 200 inches per minute.

How does humidity affect MIG welding?

High humidity levels, especially above 70%, can introduce moisture into the welding arc, potentially causing porosity in the weld bead. This defect can decrease weld strength by up to 40%.

How much can improper gas shielding add to my welding costs?

Poor gas shielding can lead to frequent rework and material replacement. Depending on the scale, this can increase costs by hundreds or even thousands of dollars monthly.

Why is electrode stick-out length important?

The wrong electrode stick-out can decrease the welding current, leading to a raised weld bead. Ideally, the stick-out should be between 1/4 to 3/8 inches.

How does ambient temperature influence weld height?

Welding in colder environments can cause rapid cooling rates, resulting in high welds or cracking. In hotter conditions, there's a risk of burn-through. Adjusting equipment settings based on ambient temperature is vital.

What happens if I use the wrong welding wire material?

Using inappropriate wire for a base metal can reduce the weld's strength by up to 50% and increase susceptibility to corrosion, potentially shortening the component's lifespan from 10 years to just 2-3 years.

How much does the diameter of the welding wire matter?

Selecting the right diameter ensures optimal fusion and efficiency. For thin materials, a 0.023-inch wire costing around $25 for a 2-pound spool is ideal. For thicker metals, a 0.045-inch wire, priced at about $40 for a 2-pound spool, is recommended.

Scroll to Top